MCOL Memberships:  the essential professional on-line companion  click here to enter the member site
 MCOL WEEKEND  October 18, 2003 | Volume 6, Issue 38

Quote of the Week: "It doesn't surprise me that the union is trying to hang on to such rich benefits. But it's just not realistic. No employer can continue to absorb the double-digit increases we've seen in health-care costs over the past few years or expect to pass them along to customers." Jim Foreman, Managing Director, Health and Welfare, Towers Perrin

In This Issue:

MCOL Tidbits: Striking Out


Weekly News:
1. Solving The Health Care Insurance Mess
2. Tenet gets another subpoena from Justice Department
3. Health care costs spark Calif. strikes
4. Minnesota Governor Announces Plan to Import Drugs
5. Massachusetts Lawmakers Ask FDA To Reverse Position on Prescription Drugs Reimportation
6. U.S. still top health-care spender
7. 'Developing consensus' to have wealthy pay more for Medicare
8. Ousted HealthSouth Chief Taking the Fifth
9. The Hidden Snags in Health-Care Pools
10. Medicare Premium to Increase by 13.5 Percent Next Year
 
Member Web Site:

There's lots more in addition to the above features. Be sure to visit your member web site!

Solutions:

HealthcareWebSummit
HealthQuest Publishers
MCOL Software
Managed Care Store
HMO Market Reports
HealthExecWire
ConferenceLand

Discounts: MCOL Paid Members get 50% off HealthcareWebSummit events; 10% off MCOL products; 5% off all other products through the Managed Care Store and special discounts for selected conferences
 SPONSOR MESSAGE
SPONSOR MESSAGE: 2nd Annual Managing Health Care Costs Healthcare Web Summit
2nd Annual Managing Health Care Costs Healthcare Web Summit
November 3rd through November 14th, 2003
http://www.healthwebsummit.com/manhcc.htm
 
The second annual web summit on emerging trends and solutions in dealing with double digit cost increases is a web-only event that you won't want to miss! 
Summit Faculty include:
William A. Bennett, Senior Vice President/Marketing & Communications, Mercy Health Plan
Michael Carter, Vice President, Hay Group
William J. DeMarco, President & CEO, DeMarco and Associates
Sam Ho, SVP & Chief Medical Officer, PacifiCare Health Systems
Max Jack, President & CEO, Direct Health Networks, Inc.
Paul H. Keckley, Senior Fellow, Vanderbilt Center for Better Health
Jennifer Kingsley Wilson, Vice President, AEL RX
Vince Kuraitis, Principal, Better Health Technologies
Henry Loubet, Senior Vice President, Strategic Planning, Keenan and Associates
Jerry Reeves, President and CEO, WorldDoc, Inc.
Dan Rhodes, Vice President, Sales & Marketing, Delta Health Systems
Lisa Rubino, SVP, Chief Executive Individual & Gov't Bus. Unit, Blue Shield of California
Dennis Streveler, Ph.D., Professor, Medical Informatics, University of Hawaii
Craig S. Stern, PharmD, MBA, President, Pro Pharma Pharamceutical Consultants, Inc.
Claire Thayer, Vice President Research and Development, MCOL
Eric Zimmerman, Vice President, Product Marketing, RelayHealth

Live AudioConference/ Webcasts: For no additional fee (other than any long distance phone charges) attendees can participate in Live Audioconference / Webcasts of selected presentations during the web summit. Each session is scheduled at separate times and dates for 45 minutes each. Live sessions include: Tiered Networks and Benefits, Sam Ho, MD, PacifiCare Health Systems; A Comprehensive Strategy for Controlling Health Care Benefit Costs; Michael Carter, Hay Group; Past, Present and Future, Evolution of the Health Plan through 2013, William DeMarco; DeMarco and Associates;  Leveraging Emerging Consumer Technologies To Improve ROI for Disease Management, Vince Kuraitis, Better Health Technologies; and What Happens When Doctors and Patients Can Connect Online using webVisits?, Eric Zimmerman, RelayHealth Corporation; Updates and Predictions for Pharmacy Benefit Issues, Craig S. Stern, PharmD, MBA, Pro Pharma Pharamceutical Consultants, Inc.

Registration: Individual Registration Fee: $95; Web Summit CD-ROM: $20 for attendees; $115 for non-attendees after November 14th.
 
To Register go to https://www.managedcarestore.com/summit.htm or call the Healthcare Web Summit office at 209.577.4888 for additional information.

 WEEKLY NEWS

1. Solving The Health Care Insurance Mess
After four years of double-digit increases in health care costs, companies and workers alike are pining for a lull. Unfortunately, the whirlwind of climbing premiums is showing no sign of abating. Just as last year's 13.9% increase is starting to sink in, new reports are already predicting further double-digit growth in 2004.
Forbes, October 16, 2003
http://www.forbes.com/2003/10/16/cx_al_1016healthcare.html

2. Tenet gets another subpoena from Justice Department
Tenet Healthcare Corp. said it has received another subpoena from the Justice Department requesting information about certain Medicare payments.
San Francisco Chronicle, October 17, 2003
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/news/archive/2003/10/17/financial0917EDT0031.DTL

3. Health care costs spark Calif. strikes
Daniel Lucra, 19, just wants to keep his health care in case he gets sick or hurt on his job behind the deli counter at Albertson’s, where slippery floors and sharp blades can cause injuries. Cashier Linda Young, who has worked 10 years for Albertson’s, has two kids, 8 and 10, and will have to pay $40 for every doctor visit if the company succeeds in cutting health benefits.
Peoples Weekly World, October 17, 2003
http://www.pww.org/article/articleview/4233/1/185/
 
4. Minnesota Governor Announces Plan to Import Drugs
In a move designed to pressure national leaders to tackle high prescription drug prices, Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty on Thursday announced a landmark plan to help Minnesotans import U.S.-manufactured drugs from Canadian pharmacies.
[St. Paul] Pioneer Press, October 17, 2003
http://www.twincities.com/mld/pioneerpress/news/local/7032399.htm

5. Massachusetts Lawmakers Ask FDA To Reverse Position on Prescription Drugs Reimportation
FDA officials should reverse their current position on the reimportation of lower-cost U.S.-manufactured prescription drugs from Canada and develop a system to allow the practice, according to a letter to FDA Commissioner Dr. Mark McClellan from members of the Massachusetts congressional delegation, the Boston Globe reports.
KaiserNetwork.org, October 16, 2003
http://www.kaisernetwork.org/daily_reports/rep_index.cfm?DR_ID=20387

6. U.S. still top health-care spender
The United States continues to far outspend other developed nations on health care, according to data released Thursday. Americans’ health costs now account for 13.9 percent of gross domestic product, or $4,887 per person. Yet Americans continue to lag in certain key indicators of health.
MSNBC, October 16, 2003
http://www.msnbc.com/news/980802.asp

7. 'Developing consensus' to have wealthy pay more for Medicare
Lawmakers negotiating a Medicare prescription drug bill report a growing consensus for higher-income seniors to pay more than other Medicare beneficiaries for their health coverage.
USA Today, October 16, 2003
http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/2003-10-16-means-medicare_x.htm

8. Ousted HealthSouth Chief Taking the Fifth
Saying he was denied "a fair hearing" by Congress, ousted HealthSouth chief Richard Scrushy invoked his constitutional privilege Thursday and refused to answer lawmakers' questions in their investigation of the $2.5 billion accounting scandal engulfing the major medical services company.
Miami Herald, October 16, 2003
http://www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/7026947.htm

9. The Hidden Snags in Health-Care Pools
In theory, small businesses banding together for cheaper rates makes sense. In practice, legal constraints and limited bargaining power are big obstacles
Business Week, October 16, 2003
http://www.businessweek.com/smallbiz/content/oct2003/sb20031016_6581_sb025.htm

10. Medicare Premium to Increase by 13.5 Percent Next Year
The Medicare premium will shoot up next year to $66.60 a month, an increase of 13.5 percent, or $7.90 a month, the Bush administration said on Wednesday. That is one of the largest increases in the history of the program.
New York Times, October 15, 2003
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/10/16/politics/16MEDI.html?ex=1066968000&en=479c56834ab9a846&ei=5040&partner=MOREOVER
 
MCOL TIDBITS

Striking Out

It isn't just the Cubs or Red Sox who have heard "strike" more often than they wished.

California has been hit by a wave of high profile union strikes over health benefits. A Southern California strike affecting three chain supermarkets alone affects 859 stores and 70,000 workers. The Los Angeles Times notes in an October 15th article, "In fact, at least half the strikes in California this year have been staged over health benefits, according to Ken Jacobs, a researcher at the UC Berkeley Labor Center. He counted 11 such work stoppages in a four-month period this year in Northern California." Jacobs also noted "unionized workers in California were 42% more likely to be covered by health insurance than those who were not in unions."

The California strikes are making significant national news. Why? Because the health benefits strike issue is spreading around the country. The LA Times article quotes said Kate Bronfenbrenner, director of Labor Education Research at Cornell University. "It's at the core of every major contract struggle. And it's going to be an issue until we see some national solutions." The New York Times quotes Greg Denier, director of communications for the United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) union: "This battle is growing nationwide. What's happening is that contracts are up across the country in different areas. The employers are dedicated to eliminating affordable health care for employees, so the national health care crisis is being played out on the picket line." And in fact, a new UFCW strike over health benefits has just hit the Kroger stores in Kentucky, Ohio and West Virginia.

The UFCW union, representing the Southern California supermarket workers, has established a web site advocating their health care benefits strike position, and present their calculations of the impact of the proposed cost sharing increases at http://www.saveourhealthcare.org/shifting.html . They claim, even with "no major medical tragedies" a "single worker, with PPO coverage, would see his or her out-of-pocket increase from $234 per year to $1,480" or "if he or she is in the HMO plan would see his or her costs increase from $54 to $1,200 per year." They also provide figures for out of pocket increases for family workers and those with major medical conditions.

On the other hand, these UFCW covered workers currently have no premium deduction for entire family coverage, which a rich benefit that a Kaiser Family Foundation study pointed out is only available at 4% of companies nationwide. The stores providing these benefits compete on price against non-union Wal-Mart, and according to a recent BenefitNews Connect article "Wal-Mart's health plan does not cover retirees at all, nor does it pay for employees' everyday health expenses like flu shots, eye exams and child vaccinations. Further, plan deductibles can reach as high as $1,000 and (employee) premiums have risen 50% over the past two years. Considering most Wal-Mart employees earn less than $10 per hour, the out-of-pocket expenses make a considerable dent in income." 

The UAW announced last week ratification of agreements with GM, Ford and the Chrysler Group of DaimlerChrysler that severely restrict those employer's ability to pass along various forms of additional cost sharing in their benefit packages.

Indeed, the heart of the issue is increased employee cost sharing, or "cost shifting" as the unions call it. This favored response during the past two years by employers and health plans to double digit health care cost increases is running into stiffer opposition as multi-year union agreements face renewal.

Watson Wyatt earlier this month released an employer survey indicating that increased cost sharing is expected to slow down significantly in 2004. They noted 56% of respondents indicated they were requiring employees to bear increased benefit costs in 2003, while only 18% expected to take further steps along these lines in 2004.

It would appear the significant remaining targets for increased cost sharing are those with the richest of benefits: little or no payroll deductions, very small flat dollar copayments for services, etc. In other words, a number of union plans. The unions, in response appear to continue to be more willing to strike over these benefits than over wages.

For more information:

Rising Health-Care Costs at Heart of Labor Strife
LA Times October 15, 2003
http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-health14oct14,1,5310682.story?coll=la-home-headlines 

California Supermarket Strike Deters Shoppers
New York Times, October 14, 2003
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/10/14/national/14GROC.html 

Save our health care web site
UFCW sponsored site
http://www.saveourhealthcare.org 

Wal-Mart health plan brings new meaning to bare bones 
BenefitNews Connect, October 2, 2003 
http://www.benefitnews.com/finance/detail.cfm?id=5145 

Benefits at heart of strike
Herald Dispatch, October 15, 2003
http://www.herald-dispatch.com/2003/October/15/LNspot.htm 

United Auto Workers Ratifies Contract With GM, Delphi
Kaiser Family Foundation Daily Health Policy Report, October 7. 2003
http://www.kaisernetwork.org/daily_reports/rep_index.cfm?DR_ID=20231 

Health-Care Rift Is the Flashpoint for MTA Strike
Los Angeles Times, October 15, 2003 
http://www.latimes.com/classified/jobs/news/la-me-medical15oct15,0,922351.story?coll=la-class-employ-jobnews 

Southern California Striking Out
CBS News, October 15, 2003
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/10/14/national/main577902.shtml 

More workers strike over healthcare benefits
Christian Science Monitor, October 16, 2003
http://www.csmonitor.com/2003/1016/p03s01-usec.html?usaNav 

Fewer Companies Plan Worker Cost-cutting Measures For Next Year, Watson Wyatt Survey Finds
Watson Wyatt Press Release, October 2, 2003
http://www.watsonwyatt.com/us/news/press.asp?ID=11900


MCOL......Positioning you for a new kind of healthcare

Copyright 2003, MCOL, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Use is restricted for MCOL Members only. No redistribution allowed.